Two algae tools, two different jobs
If you're cleaning algae off aquarium glass, you have two Seachem options that sound similar: Algae Pads and Algae Scraper Replacement Pads. But they are not interchangeable. The Algae Pads are a hand-held cleaning block, while the Replacement Pads are meant to refresh the head of a separate algae scraper tool. Knowing which one fits your routine comes down to how you like to clean and what surfaces you're working with.
What each product actually is
- Seachem Algae Pads: Seachem Algae Pads are non-scratch algae pads for glass & acrylic, made of melamine foam with micro abrasive technology and an added durable scrubbing surface. This tells you the pad is safe for both glass and acrylic, and that it works by gentle abrasion rather than chemical cleaning.

Seachem Algae Pads - Seachem Algae Scraper Replacement Pads: Seachem Algae Scraper Replacement Pads are a pack of three pads compatible with all Seachem algae scraper models, designed to restore the scraping surface. If you already own a Seachem scraper, these pads are the intended way to keep it effective; they are not a standalone cleaning tool.

Seachem Algae Scraper Replacement Pads
Key differences at a glance
- Form factor: Algae Pads are a block you hold directly. Replacement Pads attach to a scraper handle, extending your reach.
- Surface safety: Algae Pads are explicitly safe for glass and acrylic. The replacement pads are designed to protect glass and acrylic, but the supplied information does not specify the exact material.
- Packaging: Algae Pads come in a pack of 18, while Replacement Pads come in a pack of 3.
- Price: Algae Pads are priced higher (USD 20.05) than Replacement Pads (USD 3.44), reflecting the different quantities and purposes.
When to choose Seachem Algae Pads
The Algae Pads are a good fit if you prefer a simple, direct method: pick up the pad and wipe the glass. The melamine foam uses micro abrasive technology to lift algae, and it works especially well on scratches. The white color contrasts against dark algae, so you can see when an area is fully clean. Since they are chemically inert and contain no soaps or detergents, they are safe for aquarium use. However, the pad size is 4.5" x 1" x 2.5", so for larger tanks you may need to work in sections or replace the pad as it wears.
When to choose Algae Scraper Replacement Pads
If you already use a Seachem algae scraper, the Replacement Pads are the practical choice. They restore the scraping surface, helping you remove stubborn algae efficiently. They are easy to install and remove, so refreshing the tool is quick. The pack of three gives you a spare set for ongoing maintenance. The supplied information does not specify the exact material or whether they are safe for acrylic, so if you have an acrylic tank, you may want to verify compatibility before buying.
How to decide between the two
- Do you already own a Seachem scraper?: If yes, Replacement Pads are the direct fit. If not, Algae Pads work standalone.
- What surface are you cleaning?: Algae Pads are confirmed safe for glass and acrylic. Replacement Pads are described as protecting both, but the material is not confirmed.
- How much cleaning do you do?: The 18-pack of Algae Pads offers more cleaning surface over time, while the 3-pack of Replacement Pads is a smaller, cheaper refresh.
What the supplied information does not settle
The records do not specify the exact material of the Replacement Pads, so we cannot confirm whether they are also melamine foam. They also do not list the pad dimensions or whether they fit specific scraper handle sizes beyond the claim of compatibility with all Seachem algae scraper models. If you are unsure about fit, it's worth checking the scraper model you own before ordering.



